You know that moment at the grocery store when the cashier asks, “Paper or plastic?” It’s one of those questions that’s supposed to make you feel like you have a choice that actually matters.
For the longest time, I thought picking paper meant I was doing something good for the planet. It’s natural, biodegradable, and not floating around in the ocean, right?
But as I’ve learned more about sustainability, I realized that the “paper vs. plastic” debate isn’t as simple as it seems.
The truth is, neither option is as eco-friendly as we’d like to believe. Both have hidden costs for the environment that most of us never see. So, let me break it down for you — and by the end of this, you might just rethink that choice at the checkout line.
The Lifecycle of a Paper Bag
Below we are outlining the process of making a paper bag. You will see a lot of work is involved – and how it impacts our environment in negative ways.
Raw Material Extraction
At first glance, paper bags seem like the more “natural” option. They come from trees, after all. But here’s the thing — those trees have to be cut down. Logging for paper bag production contributes to deforestation, which isn’t just bad for the trees but for entire ecosystems.
Wildlife loses its habitat, soil erodes, and the carbon-absorbing power of forests is reduced. According to the Environmental Paper Network, approximately 42% of global wood harvest goes directly to paper production.
Manufacturing Process
Once the trees are cut down, they’re turned into pulp and processed into paper. This step is water-intensive, energy-heavy, and full of chemicals. To bleach paper and give it that clean, smooth look, factories use chlorine-based chemicals that can release toxic byproducts into rivers and streams.
Producing paper bags also uses a ton of water—about four times as much as plastic bags. Plus, because paper bags are heavier, transporting them requires more energy, leading to higher greenhouse gas emissions.
End-of-Life (Disposal)
At least paper is biodegradable, right? True — but that doesn’t mean it magically vanishes. If a paper bag ends up in a landfill (like most do), it decomposes in the absence of oxygen, which produces methane.
Methane is a greenhouse gas that’s 25 times more potent than carbon dioxide when it comes to trapping heat in the atmosphere. And while recycling paper is possible, it requires significant amounts of water and energy.

The Lifecycle of a Plastic Bag
Now on to the process of making a plastic bag. Again, this process is also not clean and creates environmental issues as well, just in a different way.
Raw Material Extraction
Unlike paper, plastic isn’t “natural” — it’s synthetic, made from fossil fuels like crude oil and natural gas. Extracting these resources has its own set of environmental consequences, including oil spills, fracking-related earthquakes, and habitat destruction.
About 4% of the world’s oil production is used to make plastic, and another 4% is used to power the production process.
Manufacturing Process
Producing plastic is a highly efficient process in terms of energy use, which is one of the reasons plastic bags are so cheap to produce. But efficiency isn’t the same as “clean.” The production process releases toxins into the air and contributes to global warming.
According to the Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL), plastic production emits about 850 million metric tons of greenhouse gases annually, and those numbers are projected to rise as plastic production increases.
End-of-Life (Disposal)
We all know plastic is a problem. It doesn’t decompose like paper. Instead, it breaks down into tiny particles called microplastics, which can be found in the ocean, soil, and even our drinking water.
Less than 10% of plastic bags are recycled in the U.S., and the rest end up in landfills, incinerators, or, worse, in the ocean. If you’ve seen pictures of sea turtles tangled in plastic, you know how devastating this can be.

Related: Vegan Leather vs Real Leather: Which is More Eco-Friendly?
Environmental Impact Comparison: Paper vs. Plastic
Carbon Footprint
Which is worse for the planet in terms of carbon emissions — paper or plastic? It’s not as straightforward as you might think. Paper bags produce 3 times more greenhouse gas emissions during production than plastic bags.
Why? Because paper production requires more water, energy, and chemicals. On the flip side, plastic has a smaller carbon footprint during production but a much larger impact after disposal, especially when it ends up in oceans.
Water Consumption
When it comes to water usage, paper is the clear loser. Paper production consumes around four times more water than plastic production. Given how critical water conservation is in drought-prone areas (like much of the western U.S.), this is a major issue.
Even paper towels and toilet paper have sustainability issues due to many of the reasons in this article.
Waste & Landfill Impact
Landfills are full of paper and plastic, but they behave very differently. Paper biodegrades, which sounds great, but in landfills (where oxygen is limited), it releases methane. Meanwhile, plastic doesn’t biodegrade at all — it just sits there for centuries, slowly breaking down into microplastics that pollute the environment.
Recycling & Reusability
Recycling paper is more common than recycling plastic, but it’s still an energy-intensive process. Plastic recycling is even more difficult. Unlike paper, which can be recycled several times, plastic is often “downcycled” — meaning it becomes a lower-quality product like park benches or carpet fibers.
Did you know that in 2018, the United States generated a whopping 35.7 million tons of plastic waste?
Yet, only 8.5% of that was recycled, according to EPA. That means over 27 million tons of plastic ended up in landfills, contributing to long-term environmental harm. PET bottles, which are commonly used for water and soda, had a slightly better recycling rate at 26.8%, but it’s still far from ideal.
The Hidden Costs of Each Choice
Deforestation & Habitat Loss (Paper)
When I learned that paper bags were tied to deforestation, I was shocked. I always thought I was doing the “right thing” by choosing paper over plastic. But when forests are cleared for paper production, animals lose their homes, biodiversity suffers, and the Earth’s natural carbon sink is reduced.
Fossil Fuel Dependence (Plastic)
Plastic bags are a byproduct of the fossil fuel industry, which means that by supporting plastic production, we’re also supporting oil drilling, fracking, and the emissions that come with it. This industry is a leading contributor to climate change.
Waste Management Costs
Who pays for all this waste? We do — through taxes and city waste management fees. It costs cities millions to clean up plastic waste, and coastal towns face even higher costs to remove plastic pollution from beaches.
The Role of Consumer Behavior
When it comes to sustainability, our choices as consumers have more power than we realize. It’s easy to blame big corporations for pollution and waste, but the truth is, every single purchase we make sends a message. The more we demand single-use items, the more companies will produce them. But when we shift our habits, companies are forced to take notice.
The Single-Use Mindset
I’ll be honest — I’ve fallen into the single-use trap more times than I’d like to admit. It’s so convenient to grab a bag at the store without a second thought. And sometimes, I’d even forget to bring my reusable bags from the car. Sound familiar? This “take it and toss it” culture is one of the biggest reasons why paper and plastic bags continue to flood the market.
But here’s the catch: single-use items are designed for convenience, not sustainability. We use them for a few minutes, but their environmental impact lasts for years (sometimes centuries, in the case of plastic). This cycle of quick use and slow degradation is at the heart of the waste problem.
How Our Habits Can Change the System
It might sound cliché, but small changes really do add up. Imagine if everyone who reads this blog started bringing their own reusable bag to the store. That one small action would prevent millions of paper and plastic bags from entering circulation each year. Here are a few simple shifts I’ve made in my daily routine:
- Keep reusable bags in the car: I always forget them if I don’t.
- Say no to a bag for small purchases: If I’m buying one or two items, I just carry them.
- Reuse the bags I already have: I used to hoard plastic bags under my sink. Now, I actually reuse them instead of just collecting them.
It’s not about being perfect. It’s about being intentional. The more we normalize bringing our own bags, the less “normal” it becomes to see single-use paper and plastic everywhere.
Shifting Social Norms
Change happens when people start talking about it. If you’ve ever noticed how trendy reusable water bottles became, you’ve seen this process in action. Reusable bags are on a similar path. Cities like San Francisco, New York, and Portland have banned or taxed single-use plastic bags, which nudges people toward reusables. And trust me, it works.
According to a 2024 report from the Public Interest Network, plastic bag bans are making a significant impact.
In five states and several major cities — affecting over 12 million people — these bans have resulted in a reduction of about 6 billion single-use plastic bags each year. To put that into perspective, that’s enough plastic bags to circle the earth 42 times. The bans also have a visible impact on the environment.
In areas where bans are in place, there have been reports of a one-third reduction in the number of plastic bags found littering streets, parks, and waterways. This means cleaner neighborhoods, healthier ecosystems, and fewer hazards for wildlife.
I’ve noticed this change in my own community. A few years ago, reusable bags were something only the “eco-conscious” crowd used. Now, it’s become a habit for people of all ages. It’s no longer seen as “trendy” — it’s just something we do.
I used to feel awkward pulling out a crumpled reusable bag from my purse, but now, I see people doing the same thing all the time. Change is contagious, and it all starts with a few early adopters.
The power of these bans goes beyond the individual. Retailers adjust, too. When single-use bags aren’t free, stores have an incentive to offer more sustainable options, and customers feel a stronger push to bring their own. This is how system-wide change happens — one person, one store, and one community at a time.
What is the Most Sustainable Choice?
So, if paper and plastic aren’t the answer, what is? The best option is reusable bags — but not all reusable bags are created equal.
Reusable Bags
If you’ve ever wondered, “Are reusable bags really better?” the answer is yes — but with a catch. Not all reusable bags are created equal. Some have a larger environmental footprint at the production stage, but they pay off in the long run. Let me explain:
- Cloth Bags (Cotton, Hemp, Jute, etc.)
Cotton bags have become a sustainability symbol, but here’s the twist: they actually have a high production cost. Cotton farming requires large amounts of water, fertilizers, and pesticides.
In fact, it takes about 131 uses of a cotton tote bag to make up for its production impact, according to National Geographic’s Sustainable Shopping Guide. If you’re like me and you’ve bought a new tote bag at every farmer’s market, you’ll want to reconsider. The best option is to use the bags you already have. - Recycled PET (rPET) Bags
These bags are made from recycled plastic bottles (like water or soda bottles), and they have a significantly smaller impact than cotton bags. Since they’re made from materials already in circulation, they’re essentially “upcycled.” They’re also more durable than cotton, and many of them fold up small enough to fit in your purse or glove compartment. - Nylon or Polyester Bags
While not as sustainable as recycled bags, nylon and polyester totes are lightweight, durable, and often foldable. They’re better than single-use bags but not as eco-friendly as rPET. Still, if you already have them, keep using them!
The Bottom Line: The most sustainable bag is the one you already own. Whether it’s a canvas tote, a recycled PET bag, or even that stash of plastic bags under your sink, the key is to use it over and over.
No Bag at All (Go Bag-Free)
This option might sound a little extreme, but it’s easier than you think. If you’re just picking up a bottle of ketchup or a single loaf of bread, you don’t need a bag at all. I’ve made this shift, and it feels surprisingly good to walk out of the store with just my items in hand. Not only does it cut down on waste, but it’s also one less thing to carry around.
If you have a backpack, purse, or tote bag with you (like I often do), you can just put your items inside and skip the checkout bag entirely. It’s a simple solution that avoids the “paper vs. plastic” dilemma entirely.
Use What You Already Have
Here’s a radical idea: don’t buy new reusable bags. The most sustainable option is to reuse what’s already in your home. I used to think I needed to buy fancy eco-friendly bags to be more sustainable, but I realized I already had a stack of plastic bags under my sink. Instead of tossing them, I started bringing them back to the store and reusing them.
If you have old tote bags, use them. If you have backpacks, use them. If you have old drawstring gym bags, use them. The goal is to keep them in use as long as possible to offset their production footprint.
Rethink Shopping Habits
This part might be uncomfortable to hear, but sometimes the best option is to buy less in the first place. Do we really need so many “stuff” bags? I’ve started asking myself this question more often.
Instead of buying a few things here and there (which means I’m always taking a bag), I plan bigger shopping trips and bring enough reusable bags with me. It’s a small change that makes a big impact.
Here’s another idea: buy more things in bulk. Many stores have bulk bins where you can bring your own container. Some zero-waste stores even let you refill jars with shampoo, laundry detergent, or hand soap. These methods cut down on both packaging and the need for bags.
The key is to use what you already have. Got an old tote? Keep using it. Have a stash of plastic bags under your sink? Use them until they wear out. The most sustainable choice is always to reduce consumption first.
Rethinking the “Paper vs. Plastic” Debate
Next time you’re at the checkout line and they ask, “Paper or plastic?” you’ll know the answer isn’t as simple as it sounds. Neither choice is great for the planet, and both come with hidden costs. The real solution is to step away from single-use options entirely.
At the end of the day, the most eco-friendly option is the one you already have on hand. So, bring your own bag, skip the single-use mindset, and know that every small choice adds up!